By Andy O’Brien
On September 16, the Sanford City Council voted 4-3 to move forward with a contract with Georgia-based security company Flock Safety for a free, 60-day trial of its cloud Automatic License Plate Reader (ALPR) cameras. The cameras will be installed at four intersections and a roundabout in downtown Sanford.
Civil liberties advocates fear that the surveillance cameras will violate state privacy laws and could be used against the immigrant community. The 24/7 live action cameras continuously record license plate numbers, as well as color and brand of vehicles, and upload the data into a nationwide database.
Police departments can then do nationwide searches of the database to track vehicles all over the country. According to its website, Flock Safety has installed over 80,000 cameras – powered by artificial intelligence – for 5,000 law enforcement agencies across the U.S.
Police officers can use the data to investigate crimes. They can pinpoint where a vehicle was at a certain time and map out its movements across several days. The program also allows police to create a “hotlist” to receive real-time alerts for vehicles of interest, and share information with other law enforcement, including immigration enforcement agencies.
The cost to Sanford for a Flock subscription would include a $3.3 million initial installation cost and a $23,000 annual subscription fee.
At the Sept. 16 meeting, Sanford police officials said that the scanners are needed to investigate serious crimes in the community. Surveilling the entire downtown with the help of Flock cameras would allow them to quickly corroborate victims’ statements, exonerate suspects, confirm alibis, and solve cases, they said. Currently, police in Sanford must rely on cameras on businesses or private homes to investigate crimes.
Police officials told the council that investigations of 45 recent incidents could have benefitted from data collected by Flock cameras.
Sanford Police Chief Eric Small, who is currently seeking the Republican nomination to challenge U.S. Rep. Chellie Pingree, told the council there has been an “outcry” from the community for more policing to tackle crime. He said the cameras were the “equivalent of hundreds of officers” and argued that the technology is an enhanced version of tools police already use.
He also said that the Flock cameras would only be used for serious crimes like murders, rapes, assaults, and drug trafficking, as well locating missing juveniles and seniors.
At the same time, he told the council, “I can just run around the Midtown Mall and run every plate just for the fun of it to see if anyone has any warrants or if anyone’s license is suspended.”
Police officials insisted they will be following state privacy laws and will only be using it for criminal investigations, public safety, or “a mass public safety incident.”
Sanford Police Lieutenant Colleen Adams spoke to the council about limits that would be placed on use of the cameras by police: “There is a state law regarding the use of these cameras, stating that we can only use these cameras for criminal investigations, public safety, a mass public safety incident. … We actually have to have a legit reason.”
The department will periodically audit the program, Adams said, to make sure officers are following the policy and state law.
ACLU questions legality of cameras
The American Civil Liberties Union of Maine questioned whether such a mass collection of personal data is legal. ACLU of Maine Policy Director Michael Kebede pointed to a state law that requires an automatic license plate recognition system “use only information entered by a law enforcement officer and based on specific and articulable facts of concern for safety, wrongdoing, or criminal investigation, or pursuant to a civil order or records from the National Crime Information Center database or an official published law enforcement bulletin.”
In other words, the law only allows police to input a plate number into the system so that they would get an alert if the vehicle in question passes by a camera.
“But that doesn’t seem to be what they’re contemplating in Sanford,” said Kebede. “It seems what they’re trying to do in Sanford is to collect information on anyone who comes through the city, hold it for three weeks, and if they want to look for anything within that haystack, they’ll run a search.”
Kebede questioned whether the approach approved by the council is legal, and asserted that capturing and storing all of the license plates and other information of vehicles amounts to an unlawful warrantless search in violation of the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition on unreasonable searches and seizures. Kebede noted that the Supreme Court has ruled that law enforcement needs a warrant to use cell phone and cell site location records to track movements.
“My reading of the statute says that you can’t just collect everyone’s license plate information and hold it and then do the search within that vast database,” Kebede said.
At the City Council meeting, police and city councilors dismissed privacy concerns about the Flock cameras, saying the public is already being watched by other surveillance cameras at local businesses, and that software on smartphones also tracks data. Adams said it’s already legal to follow someone around, record them on video, and post to social media.
Councilor Maura Herlihy also pushed back against concerns about privacy, saying “If you’re afraid for your own personal safety, you should be off the internet, you should be off your social media, you should be careful about what you carry around for a phone because you can be tracked by your phone. There are far more things to be concerned about.”
But criminal defense attorney Dagan Vandemark of Springvale countered at the meeting that there is a “major difference” between carrying a smart phone and using social media, and the police tracking one’s movements and uploading the information into a nationwide database.
“This is not just a First Amendment concern, this is a Fourth Amendment concern because when law enforcement wants to install a tracker on someone’s car they need probable cause, they need a warrant,” Vandemark said. “But here we have cameras that are owned by a $7.5-billion company that’s going to do God knows what with it in the future.”
A recent lawsuit against Flock Safety revealed that 176 of its cameras in Norfolk, Virginia, tracked a retired veteran’s location 526 times between Feb. 19 and July 2 of this year.
Kebede declined to comment on whether the ACLU would file its own lawsuit, but cautioned that the City of Houlton, Maine, has had to spend significant funds to fight a lawsuit concerning its use of surveillance cameras that employ facial recognition technology.
“Houlton was sued by one of their residents, and his lawsuit blew a massive hole in their budget,” said Kebede. “So this could be a fast track towards fiscal catastrophe for Sanford if a resident sues them.”
While Sanford police maintain that the cameras will only be used in the case of serious crimes, Vandemark speculated that the program will be most commonly used for minor infractions like operating after suspension. She argued that the legal burden of proof to access Flock’s database is far lower than any other burden of proof required for law enforcement to perform searches.
Flock database could be used by ICE
Civil liberties groups have expressed concerns that Flock’s cameras are being used by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to carry out the mass deportation agenda of President Donald Trump’s administration, which has come under fire both for violating the constitutional right to due process, and for its abusive treatment of detainees.
The tech news outlet 404 Media, obtained records of nationwide usage of the Flock database and found that local police have been using it on behalf of ICE for immigration enforcement purposes.
This year, several cities across the country – including Austin, Texas, and Denver, Colorado – have canceled their contracts with Flock Safety over concerns that it is being used for immigration enforcement and for tracking people who are trying to evade anti-abortion laws.
Sanford’s police chief said his department has not been asked to work with ICE but would do so if the agency requests the department’s assistance.
“As it stands right now, we haven’t had to [work with ICE],” said Small. “ICE has not come to the Sanford Police Department. Will they? I don’t know. But if they do, will we work with them? Yes, we will, just like we work with the FBI, [Drug Enforcement Administration], and any other federal agency.”
Small acknowledged that Gov. Janet Mills is currently holding a bill (LD 1971) passed last session by the Maine Legislature that would prohibit local law enforcement from working with immigration enforcement agencies.
“If LD 1971 is passed then we won’t be able to work with ICE,” Small said.





