By Andy O’Brien

In the wake of a firestorm of controversy over the doxxing of a high school student by Rep. Laura Libby (R-Dist. 64, Auburn), the Joint Standing Committee on Judiciary of the Maine Legislature is considering a bill to prohibit future online attacks on minors. Doxxing is when someone discloses personal identifying information, usually on the internet, without the individual’s consent and usually with malicious intent. 

Last week, the Maine House of Representatives voted on party lines to censure Libby for naming a transgender high school athlete and uploading her photo on a social media post that was subsequently shared thousands of times in an attempt to cast scorn and shame on the student. As a result of the Legislature’s censure, Libby is not allowed to vote on bills or speak on the House floor until she publicly apologizes. So far, Libby has refused to apologize.

On Tuesday, educators, parents, and LGBTQ+ advocates called on lawmakers to pass LD 537, “An Act to Prohibit the Doxing of a Minor and to Authorize a Related Civil Action,” which would allow parents to sue individuals for doxxing their child. This would include disclosing the minor’s personal identifying information without their consent in ways that cause them to be stalked, harassed, physically harmed, or to fear for their safety. 

ADVERTISEMENT

The bill is supported by the Maine School Boards Association, the Maine Superintendents Association, the Maine Principals Association, the Maine Medical Association, LGBTQ rights groups, and others. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Maine, which has opposed some doxxing bills in other states, did not testify either in support of or against the bill.

The bill’s sponsor, Rep. Melanie Sachs (D-Freeport, Dist.102), told the committee that she was sponsoring LD 537 because of an incident involving a transgender youth in her district who was targeted online by a conservative activist in 2023. She said that the activist repeatedly and negatively posted about the child and discussed the individual on podcasts, resulting in news coverage of the minor that spread nationally and internationally.

“As a clinician, as a mom, as a human being – I was frankly horrified,” said Sachs. “I called the Maine Attorney General’s office to ask what recourse this family might have to hold this adult accountable for their actions, and to stop what I described as bullying and atrocious behavior of an adult directed towards a minor.”

She said she was shocked to learn that Maine has no laws preventing an adult from doxxing children. Sachs noted that Arizona, California, Connecticut, Kentucky, and Missouri all have laws that impose criminal penalties for adults who dox minors, while Nevada and Oregon allow civil actions to be brought in cases involving doxxing. 

Attorney General Aaron Frey testified in support of LD 537, noting that when the child in Sachs’ district was targeted for online harassment by angry adults, it disrupted the child’s life  and caused what he called “deep trauma to them and their family.” He said that regulating people’s online behavior is challenging, due to potential conflicts with the First Amendment’s guarantee of free speech. However, he believes  LD 537 would survive a constitutional challenge. The committee will schedule a work session for the bill in the coming weeks.

Read more related stories